December 10, 2004
Why Republicans shun academia
Jonathan Chait has a fantastic editorial in the L.A. Times, entitled "Why Academia Shuns Republicans". His article actually explains why Republicans shun academia -- because of spreading GOP anti-intellectualism. But it also has some fun parts:A few weeks ago, a pair of studies found that Democrats vastly outnumbered Republicans among professors at leading universities. Conservatives gleefully seized upon this to once again flagellate academia for its liberal bias. Am I the only person who fails to understand why conservatives see this finding as vindication? After all, these studies show that some of the best-educated, most-informed people in the country overwhelmingly reject the GOP. Why is this seen as an indictment of academia, rather than as an indictment of the Republican Party? Conservatives have a ready answer. The only reason faculties lean so far to the left is that deans, administrators and entire university cultures systematically discriminate against conservatives. They don't, however, have much evidence to back this up. Mostly, they assume that the leftward tilt is prima facie evidence of anti-conservative discrimination. (Yet, when liberals hold up minority underrepresentation at some institutions as proof of discrimination, conservatives are justifiably skeptical.)I especially like this reductio ad absurdum:
But the rise of fashionable left-wing scholarship can be blamed for only a tiny part of the GOP's problem. The studies showing that academics prefer Democrats to Republicans also show that this preference holds in hard sciences as well as social sciences. Are we to believe that higher education has fallen prey to trendy multiculturalist engineering, or that physics departments everywhere suppress conservative quantum theorists?I wish there were more articles like this, showing how bogus most of the cries of "liberal bias" are. The fact that there aren't more is prima facie evidence of a conservative media bias. ;) [Via Yglesias]
Posted by Jeffrey at December 10, 2004 1:23 PM
What is a TrackBack? Learn more here. TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.geekable.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/620
Listed below are links to the 0 weblogs that reference 'Why Republicans shun academia' from Geekable.com.
http://www.geekable.com/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/620
Listed below are links to the 0 weblogs that reference 'Why Republicans shun academia' from Geekable.com.

